1903 206 It is as clear to the Christian that he is to expect suffering, scorn, injury, persecution, and in short tribulation of every sort in and from the world, as that grace has given him the richest privileges in Christ. "These things I have spoken to you," says our Lord, "that in me ye might have peace. In the world ye have (not merely "ye shall have," as in inferior witnesses) tribulation; but be of good courage: I have overcome the world" (John 16:33). Also in Acts 14:22 in establishing the souls of the disciples, exhorting them to abide in the faith, the word is that "through many tribulations we must enter into the kingdom of God." So the great apostle could say on the one hand, "I ask that ye faint not at my tribulations for you, which is your glory" (Eph. 3:13), and, on the other, "to you it was granted in behalf of Christ, not only to believe on him but also to suffer for his sake, having the same conflict which ye saw in me and now hear of in me" (Phil. 1:29-30). "Faithful the word [is]; for if we died with [him], we shall also live together; if we endure, we shall also reign together" (2 Tim. 2:11-12). We may not all be called to suffer for Him, but if we suffer not with Him, can we look to be glorified together? Rom. 8:17. It is here that we differ essentially from the saints born in the millennial age, who therefore are reigned over, instead of reigning with Christ.
But it is quite another question, Who are the saints that pass through and come out of the great tribulation? The answer cannot be given by human feeling, nor by good men undertaking to prophesy, but by the light God has given us in the prophetic word. Vehement accusation of wresting the scriptures, of claims to infallibility, of a self-elected minority who are too privileged to be subjects of persecution, of the madness of exaggerated self-conceit, nay even of "seducing spirits," only betrays extreme party spirit, and ignorance of the true enquiry, "What says the scripture?"
The answer is plain not only on the positive side, but even on the negative.
First, and chiefly, the O.T. is explicit that "at the time of the end," when "Michael shall stand up, the great prince who stands for the children of thy people," there shall be a time of trouble (or, tribulation) such as never was since there was a nation even to that same time." It will far exceed even what accompanied the idolatrous effort of Antiochus Epiphanes, of which Dan. 11:31-32 speaks. We do hear of an "abomination that makes desolate" then set up, but not of the tribulation without parallel which Dan. 12 predicts for the end, when the abomination that makes desolate will be set up again and for the last time, Here it is incontestable that we hear only of Daniel's people, the Jews, who "at that time shall be delivered, everyone that shall be found written in the book," that is, the future elect and godly remnant.*
{*Nor is it to my mind doubtful that in Dan. 12:2 the like figure is employed, as in Isa. 26:14-20, Ezek. 37:1-14, Hosea 6:1-2; Hosea 13:14, to describe the resuscitation of the nation, not the Jews proper already so deeply tried, but those dead as it were among the nations, who will then awake, some for life everlasting, others to everlasting contempt. As this however may be contested, I merely notice the matter in this brief note.}
It is no less indisputable that our Lord refers to this very abomination standing in a holy place for those in Judea to flee to the mountains, and to the great trouble that is to follow in even stronger terms than Daniel was given to employ. The context is just as plain and certain as that of the prophet of the captivity, that He too contemplates Jewish disciples, at that time, whom He will deliver by appearing in glory as the Son of man to the discomfiture of their enemies, but also to the discriminating judgment of Israel. For the elect, not merely of the Jews (Dan. 11:22) but of the entire people Israel (Dan. 11:31) shall be gathered together from the four winds (where these are still scattered of the ten tribes undiscerned), from one end of the heavens to the other. The Lord addresses His disciples here in a personal way, which does not apply to the intermediate part, still less to what He tells us of "all the nations."
The same fact is no less observable in Mark 13 which gives in substance the first section of our Lord's prophecy as in Matthew's Gospel, but with those characteristic additions of his on the service of His name. See Mark 13:9-12, and Mark 13:34. But there is no difference in the relevant intimation that in the future crisis only "those in Judea" are concerned, and that it is a question here of "flesh being saved, and of "this generation," etc., not of resurrection and rapture on high. Jewish disciples only are in question, and deliverance coming down to the earth in displayed power and glory, instead of saints caught up by and to be with the Lord as in 1 Thess. 4.
But in Luke 21:20-24 there is, what we have in neither Matthew nor Mark (tradition notwithstanding), an explicit prediction of the approaching destruction of Jerusalem, and great distress upon the land and upon this people. Their being led captive into all the nations only he mentions, as also the remarkable and still continued sentence of Jerusalem to be trodden down by Gentiles until their proper times be fulfilled. He speaks of "days of vengeance," as indeed such they were then; and he leaves room for more at the close where in fact he speaks of distress of nations, and men fainting for fear. This is quite in character with the design of the third Gospel, which entirely omits the abomination of desolation and the unequalled tribulation, so prominent in the two preceding Gospels. Those who have (and they are legion from ancients to moderns) attempted to identify his special part with theirs, destroy their true bearing. It is from Luke 21:25 that Luke coalesces with his predecessors in what evidently belongs to the time of the end.
Secondly, Rev. 7:9-17 presents the vision of a great crowd which none could number (distinguished from the 144,000 sealed out of the twelve tribes of Israel), as that was out of every nation, and of tribes and peoples and tongues, standing before the throne and before the Lamb. They have a wholly different position from the crowned and enthroned elders and the four living creatures; so much so that one of the elders explains to the prophet who they are, and whence they came. "And he said to me, These are they that come out of the great tribulation, and they washed their robes and made them white in the blood of the Lamb." Here then we have clear evidence that grace will deliver a vast crowd of believing Gentiles out of "the great tribulation" at the time of the end. The traditional notion that it figures the church is refuted by the very phrase which limits them to Gentiles saved out of that great tribulation which is to come. They are therefore, as a special gathering out at the close, quite distinct from those heavenly saints of all times symbolised in the same scene. It would seem that the extreme severity of the future tribulation will fall in and round Jerusalem, for the Lord declares it unparalleled; but there is no reason to doubt that it then awaits all nations, if in lesser measure. It is "the great tribulation," perhaps implied in Luke's description of "distress of nations" at that very time. There are Gentile saints, as well as Jews, to emerge from it in that day, not forming one body as now in the church, but expressly distinct from it and from one another, as Rev. 7 also plainly attests.
Thirdly, there is the promise, most appropriate to the overcomers of the church in Philadelphia (Rev. 3:10), though surely not for them exclusively, "Because thou didst keep the word of my patience, I also will keep thee (not during, but) out of the hour of trial that is about to come upon the whole habitable earth, to try those that dwell upon the earth." That hour may include more than "the great tribulation"; but one knows no intelligent Christian who thinks it covers less. The faithful, the Christian saints, are here then promised to be kept out of that hour. Any geographical refuge, as was taught by B. W. Newton and others, is vain; for it will befall the whole habitable world. The heavenly saints (1 Cor. 15:43) will be caught up before that crisis comes, which is retributive for the lawlessness of the Jews and the Gentiles a wholly different kind of trouble from what is our portion as Christians.
1902 222 Thus it is plain and sure that, if we are subject to scripture, no evidence appears that the church, the Christian body, passes through the great coming tribulation before this age ends. The proof-texts apply expressly and exclusively to Jews and Gentiles, with the striking exemption from that hour of those who keep the patience of Christ. This, though pledged to the Philadelphian overcomers, no saint of sound judgment would limit to such, any more than other words of comfort similarly vouchsafed to the various seven churches.
But this is not all. With that lack of spiritual discernment, which is now and has been for ages characteristic of Christendom, the absurd error prevails, even among many earnest students of prophecy, that because all scripture is for us, our edification and use, it is therefore about us. Any serious consideration must assuredly shatter such assumption. Is it then left to uncertainty or guesswork? In no way. Nor is time the great interpreter, or history, as sages have said. Not so, but as for all scripture, so for its prophetic part, it is the Holy Spirit. Inasmuch as He inspired to write it, so does He give understanding of God's mind in it to those who wait in dependence on the Lord for it, and thus weigh well not only the text but the context, and other scriptures converging on the same point.
Those, however, who hastily take for granted that the future tribulation must be shared by the members of Christ, have gone farther astray in their zeal, and yield to random invective and rash abuse. This we may leave, and seek to help them in and by the truth, as we give heed to all they argue.
Is it said "that it is from a blend of impatience and cowardice" people look for saints to be caught up before the last tribulation? Also, "that it is by this very persecution that ALL saints in all places shall be brought to be made simultaneously ready for the Lord at His appearing?" Such thoughts, if we prefer silence on their spirit, betray a total want of divinely given intelligence. Suffering for righteousness' sake, and yet more for Christ's name, is a high privilege; and God has given it in the fullest measure to the members of Christ, though really to all saints from the beginning. Our Lord was here as in all else supreme; and as He said, The disciple is not above his Master, but every one perfected shall be as his Master. Yea rejoins the great apostle, and all that will live piously in Christ Jesus shall be persecuted. Hence the faithful, not of the world as Christ is not, should be prepared for it beyond all throughout their pilgrimage.
But the future tribulation has a quite different source and character. In its most terrible form it will be a penal infliction of God on the consummation of Jewish apostasy, when the abomination of desolation is set up in the holy place. Those who rejected and by hand of lawless men crucified their own Messiah, the Son of God, will worship the Antichrist in the temple of God, showing that he himself is God. If without parallel for severity of judicial woe, it is because of the unparalleled audacity of lawlessness, and Satan's power in the Beast of the west joining the False Prophet of the east in contempt of Jehovah and His Christ. What has this specific crisis to do with our being granted to suffer for Christ's sake? Indeed the Lord (instead of calling on the godly Jews to stay and suffer when God is thus visiting His guilty people, not only for their final apostasy but for their bowing down to the man of sin as the true God in His house) bids the godly remnant flee forthwith, regardless even of clothes or any thing else save their lives. So in the minor case of the days of vengeance that befell Jerusalem, when the murderers were destroyed and their city burnt, it was no question of suffering as a privilege, but of a retributive dealing of God; and the Lord therefore directed those that heeded His words to escape when they saw Jerusalem compassed with armies. Was this "a blend of impatience and cowardice"? Shame on the false system, which thus misleads saints to slight Christ and ignore God's word.
Undoubtedly it will be a short time of unexampled trial. And we know too that there will be martyrdom once more, and a later group answering to a former one, as Rev. 20:4 concisely assures us (cf. Rev. 6:9-11). Those who died for rejecting the Beast, like the earlier faithful, shall rise in the blessed resurrection and reign with Christ; as those whose life was spared shall enjoy the kingdom under Christ. They are both parts of the godly Jews, with converted Gentiles also, at the time of the end; but there is no union in one body like the church, which at this time is only seen symbolically, and on high, as the book of Revelation teaches.